I’ve found it very hard to find a well made and well cut button down recently. In the past year, I’ve found two great ones from up and coming designers. I get tons of complements on both of these when I where them.
The first is Marie Marot, based out of Paris. The French generally care about quality and cut so much more than we do. The beauty of these shirts, is they are very reasonably priced for their quality at $100 each. You do have to pay for shipping, but it is well worth it.
My second button down recent find is the shirts at Nomi Naomi.
I love the New Oxford wool shirts. These are more like work shirts that you can wear as a layer, as opposed to the Marie Marot shirt above. They are also beautifully made with a careful eye for attention to detail, from the corozo nut buttons to the German wool they use. All are cut and sewn in NYC. These shirts are a bit more at $260 each, but still a steal for the quality.
https://naominomi.com/collections/everything/products/the-new-oxford-moonlight-blue-merino-wool